True Crime– a memoir, a book review by Candice Louisa Daquin
True Crime – a memoir (Grand Central Publishing) a memoir by Patricia Cornwell
True Crime fulfils its promise for unflinchingly examining the complexity and origins of Cornwell’s career & personal life. It does so with seeming honesty, though no memoir is likely to be completely honest, it would ruin people. The secrets not disclosed, are for Cornwell, not us. What she does give us, as a notoriously private person, is a rare glimpse into how she became what she is today. The building blocks of her rise – not to fame – so much as to a place of survival and integrity.
If that sounds dull, it isn’t. A memoir of such a notable public figure could be dishonest or arrogant. True Crime‘s value lies in retaining the voice of Cornwall, which is precisely what elevated her fiction. Cornwell’s main character is Kaye Scarpetta but Scarpetta is in part, Cornwall and Cornwall is in part Scarpetta. We like what Cornwell thinks and how and what, because her style of writing is slightly confessional, it glimpses into Cornwell’s psyche as much as her fictional characters.
It is Cornwell herself, through the muse of her characters Scarpetta, Lucy and even Marino, that possess a familiarity, an inner voice that becomes collective. We empathize with Cornwell’s lamentations of society, her paranoia, her observations, her passions. Not always of course, sometimes she just seems like a jock who likes flying helicopters. But when she is vulnerable? It explains her enduring success.
Granted, if you’re not a Cornwell fan, you’ll likely dismiss this. It’s a great book regardless of her literary career but those who been on the journey with her, will appreciate learning more. She’s such a private person, so being privy to her disclosures, feels at times a bit intrusive. It isn’t the obligation of any writer to ‘spill’ their private lives for the hungry masses but the fame machine is oiled by information and thus, having some control over what is disseminated, is preferable to rumor.
Unsurprisingly, True Crime feels a lot like a Scarpetta novel, but more intriguing, for being true. Cornwell has been the subject of much criticism over the years and True Crime gives some background to how Cornwell learned from a very early age, what she had to do to survive. The vulnerability of her writing is deeply moving, because she’s not been given many breaks, she really had to earn them. If you experience some of the profound neglect, instability and abuse, Cornwell has, it’s not easy to climb out of that and do well, let alone as well as she has.
Having spent years hearing other people talk about Cornwell, I am glad to hear from her. To reclaim her story and tell it herself. Cornwell invented the forensic crime thriller and she’s evolved this into a myriad of female-led genres. Some of her novels aren’t as typically ‘strong’ as others, that’s inevitable with the number she’s written, but she’s also profoundly aware of the publishing machine and its pitfalls. She’s also honest about how terrifying it is when people idolize her and stalk her. She speaks to the fragility of mental and physical health.
Many can relate to this human being who began with the odds stacked against her, without the necessary support all children should have. To her struggles through spelling and dyscalculia and being told she wasn’t going to be able to do (the things she did), her spirit of competition and urge to prove to everyone who put her down or didn’t see her, that she was worth seeing. I can also relate to her incredibly honest confessions that she was unsure of herself, that she feared she’d irrevocably failed, that she was doomed.
Of all the voices in this book I think the real Patricia Cornwell is the one I gravitate toward most. The woman who is incredibly strong but has a side to her that is vulnerable. Something in Scarpetta’s musings, always felt like Cornwell and were more believable and more hard won. In True Crime we learn for the first time about her down to earth real beginnings, the neglect of her family, her meteoric rise to fame, her struggles and her demons, as well as her overcoming. She was the highest paid female author for years and her character of Kaye Scarpetta is synonymous with strength, survivorship and integrity, which is very close I suspect to the core qualities of her creator.
For those critics who say the memoir is ‘rushed’ or all over the place, I would say, this is a memoir, life is not linear. For those who say she spent too much time on her childhood and not enough on her life as a writer, I do not believe anyone should dictate to an author what they write about in their memoir. Her memoir is her life, therefore what she wants to focus on is her prerogative. We should consider the emotional effort it takes to reveal a rape, or childhood sexual abuse, or neglect. I wonder how many of us could be that honest, if we were a public figure.
Candice Louisa Daquin is a psychotherapist and editor. She currently works for Lit Fox Books (Austin TX), Life & Legends, Writers Resist and Austin Poetry Review. Candice’s debut novel ‘The Cruelty’, is an award-winning expose of cruelty and survivorship. www.candicelouisadaquin.com
![]()
